Beneficiary Designations: Why They Override Your Will and How to Check Yours

Why beneficiary forms beat your will, how each account passes, seven common mistakes, spouse and divorce rules, and a simple once-a-year check.
A smiling retired man with glasses and his adult daughter at a sunny round table with a laptop and a form marked with a green checkmark, under a family tree on the wall with portraits of three generations.

For most retirees, more money passes through beneficiary forms than through a will. A form you filled out 20 years ago decides who gets your IRA, your 401(k) and your life insurance, no matter what your will says. Here is how each account works, the mistakes that send money to the wrong place and a simple way to check yours.

Walter, 72, lost his wife Ruth three years ago. He updated his will right away and assumed the rest would follow. When his daughter helped him sit down with every account, they found three problems. His IRA still named Ruth, with no backup, so it would go to his estate. His life insurance named his three children equally, but his son died last year, and the form would split that share between the other two instead of passing it to his son’s children. And his savings account named his granddaughter, who is 15 and cannot take the money on her own. Fixing all three took about an hour.

Key takeaways

  • Retirement accounts, life insurance, annuities and accounts marked payable-on-death or transfer-on-death go to the people named on the form. Your will does not change that.
  • Name a backup (contingent) beneficiary on every form, and check that each name still fits after a death, a marriage, a divorce or a birth.
  • Naming your estate, or leaving no one, can mean probate and, for an IRA, faster withdrawals and taxes for your heirs.
  • If you are married, federal law makes your spouse the beneficiary of your 401(k) unless your spouse signs a witnessed consent.
In this article8 sections

Why the form beats the will

A beneficiary form is a contract between you and the bank, plan or insurance company. When you die, the company pays the person named on its form. It does not read your will, and a will cannot change a form. Your will only controls what is in your name alone with no beneficiary, such as a car or a bank account with no payable-on-death name. Estate planning basics shows how the will, the forms and a trust fit together, including a Supreme Court case where a retirement plan had to pay an ex-wife.

Account by account

AccountWhat decides who gets itWhere to check
IRA and Roth IRAThe beneficiary form at the IRA firmYour online account or the firm’s form
401(k) and 403(b)The plan’s beneficiary form; a spouse by law unless they consentThe plan website or your former employer
PensionThe survivor option chosen when payments started; often cannot be changed laterThe plan’s benefit statement
Life insurance and annuitiesThe policy’s beneficiary formThe insurance company
Bank accounts and CDsA payable-on-death (POD) name, or a joint ownerYour bank
Brokerage accountsA transfer-on-death (TOD) name, or a joint ownerYour brokerage firm
Health savings accountThe HSA beneficiary formThe HSA provider
Your homeThe deed: a joint owner, a trust or, in many states, a transfer-on-death deedYour county property records
Everything else in your name aloneYour will, or state law if there is no willYour will

More than half the states now allow a transfer-on-death deed, which passes a home to the person you name without probate. Rules differ by state, so ask a local attorney before signing one.

Seven mistakes that send money to the wrong place

  1. An old name. A late spouse, an ex-spouse or a child you are no longer close to may still be on a form you signed decades ago.
  2. No backup. If your only beneficiary dies before you and there is no contingent beneficiary, the money usually goes to your estate.
  3. Naming your estate. Money that goes to the estate passes through probate, which takes time and can be public. For an IRA it can also mean faster withdrawals: if you die before your required beginning date and the estate is the beneficiary, the IRS 5-year rule applies instead of the longer schedules open to people.
  4. Naming a minor. A child cannot take the money directly. A court may have to appoint someone to manage it until the child is an adult. Many forms let you name a custodian for the child under your state’s Uniform Transfers to Minors Act, or you can name a trust.
  5. A beneficiary who gets disability benefits. An inheritance paid straight to someone on SSI or Medicaid can push them over the $2,000 savings limit and cost them their benefits. A special needs trust can receive the money instead.
  6. Forms that do not match your plan. If your will splits everything equally but your large IRA names only one child, the split will not be equal.
  7. Forgotten accounts. An old 401(k) from a job you left long ago still has its own form. The Department of Labor’s Retirement Savings Lost and Found can help you find plans you may have forgotten.

Filling out the form

  • Use each person’s full legal name, date of birth and relationship to you. Some firms also ask for a Social Security number, which helps them find the person later.
  • Name primary beneficiaries and contingent beneficiaries, and give each a percentage. The percentages in each group must add up to 100%.
  • Look for the words per stirpes. It means that if a beneficiary dies before you, that person’s share goes to their children. Without it, many forms split the share among the beneficiaries who are still alive.
  • To leave money to a trust, write the trust’s exact name and date. Trusts that receive an IRA follow special IRS rules, so have the attorney who drafted it check the wording.
  • Keep the confirmation the company sends you. A form that was never processed does not count.

Marriage, divorce and your spouse’s rights

401(k)s and similar workplace plans. Federal law generally makes your spouse the beneficiary of your 401(k). To name anyone else, your spouse must consent in writing, and the signature must be witnessed by a notary or a plan representative. Getting married can therefore override a form you signed while single.

IRAs. Federal law does not require your spouse’s consent. But in the nine community property states (Arizona, California, Idaho, Louisiana, Nevada, New Mexico, Texas, Washington and Wisconsin), your spouse may own part of the account, and many IRA firms ask for the spouse’s signature too.

Divorce. In 2018 the Supreme Court noted that 26 states had laws that automatically cancel an ex-spouse as beneficiary after a divorce, at least for some accounts. Those laws do not reach 401(k)s, pensions and life insurance provided through an employer: in 2001 the Court ruled that for those plans, federal law follows the form. The only safe move is to change every form yourself after a divorce, unless your divorce decree requires you to keep your ex as beneficiary.

What your beneficiaries will face

A spouse who inherits an IRA can usually treat it as their own. Most other heirs must empty an inherited IRA within 10 years, and the withdrawals are taxed as income. See the inherited IRA 10-year rule. Life insurance proceeds are generally free of income tax. A spouse who inherits an HSA can keep it as an HSA, but for anyone else the balance becomes taxable income in the year of your death.

Payable-on-death bank accounts also affect deposit insurance. The FDIC insures them up to $250,000 per owner for each beneficiary, up to $1,250,000 per owner at the same bank when there are five or more beneficiaries.

A once-a-year check

Pick one day a year, such as the day you do your year-end checklist, and also check after any marriage, divorce, death or birth in the family.

  1. List every account and policy, including old 401(k)s and small life insurance policies.
  2. Log in or call, and read each primary and contingent beneficiary out loud.
  3. Ask: is this person alive, still the right choice, an adult and able to manage money?
  4. Fix anything that is wrong, add backups and per stirpes where you want them, and save the confirmations.
  5. Keep the list with your will so your family knows where to look. See how to organize financial documents.

Frequently asked questions

Can my will change who gets my IRA?

No. The IRA goes to the person on the beneficiary form. If you want your will to control it, you would have to name your estate, which usually causes more problems than it solves.

Should I name my trust as beneficiary?

Sometimes, for example for a minor, a beneficiary with a disability or someone who should not get a lump sum. For retirement accounts the trust has to be written with the IRS rules in mind, so ask an estate attorney first.

Can a beneficiary turn down the money?

Yes. A beneficiary can refuse an inheritance with a written disclaimer, usually within nine months of the death and before taking any of the money. The share then passes as if that person had died first, often to the contingent beneficiary.

Does Social Security use a beneficiary form?

No. Social Security survivor benefits follow federal rules about who qualifies, such as a spouse or a young child, not a form you fill out. See what happens to Social Security when a spouse dies.


Educational note: This article is general education, not legal, tax or financial advice. Walter is an illustrative example. What happens without per stirpes, how a minor’s share is handled and how divorce affects a form depend on each company’s form and on state law. An estate planning attorney can review your forms together with your will and any trust.

Sources

Keep reading

Free printable

Estate and Care Checklist

The documents, beneficiary forms and care plans to put in place, on one printable page.

You'll also get the free RetireNerd newsletter, one short email every two weeks.

Free. We never sell your email. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy policy

About RetireNerd

Built for people navigating retirement in real life.

RetireNerd turns retirement rules, research and planning questions into practical guides and tools that are easier to understand and use.

Read why RetireNerd was built →